Letters to the Editor: March/April 2022

On neighbourhood surveillance, medical mysteries, book adaptations, and more

An illustration of a bunch of orange speech bubbles on a green background.

Send us a letter, email, or tweet, or post on our Facebook page.

An Offer You Can Refuse
I have long been interested in (read: terrified of) the surveillance potential that comes with the contemporary home-security boom that Navneet Alang outlines in his excellent article “Neighbourhood Watch” (December 2021). Perhaps it is because we are living in an unprecedented time of surveillance of our right to free movement. Still, I think that many of us who take issue with companies like Amazon and Meta (née Facebook) assume that one must participate in these profit-generating practices because they are so prevalent, as Alang reports. In fact, once I made the decision to delete Facebook and to never order from Amazon again, my quality of life didn’t dip for a moment. There are alternatives, and sometimes, the only way to win is not to play.

John Hanchar
Toronto, ON


Missed Media
I read Jessica Johnson’s article on the future of Canadian journalism eagerly (“Tomorrow’s News,” January/February). I have watched several local papers disappear here in Atlantic Canada, and having grown up reading the Guardian each day in the UK, I miss being able to read a paper edition of the Globe and Mail on the weekend. Although I share the sense that local news isn’t being read, there is still life in the local newspaper industry here in Nova Scotia. I was struck by the lack of reference to the several online publications here in Atlantic Canada that have either started as part of the movement to online media or have made that transition: the Examiner and the Coast in Halifax, allNovaScotia, and allNewfoundlandandLabrador. Not all news is in Toronto!

Keith Towse
Nova Scotia


Health Scare
Matthew Halliday’s article “New Brunswick’s Medical Mystery” (December 2021) is deeply disturbing. The predicament of these unfortunate New Brunswickers, who have had to suffer both a possible new brain disease and what seems to be a government coverup, is not only shocking but downright criminal. It’s not a stretch to liken the need for separation of public health and state to what was done with church and state historically—the only problem being a resulting need for new funding for scientific research.

Penny Oyama
Burnaby, BC


Adaptation Frustration
When it comes to adapting books to screen, as Harley Rustad explores in “The Wheel of Time: Why It’s So Hard to Accept Adaptations of Our Favourite Books,” no creator save Zack Snyder wants to make carbon copies in new mediums. If you want the book, reread the book. That said, calling out the introduction of tropes to The Wheel of Time Amazon Prime TV show—like “fridging,” when the death of a character, often female, motivates an often-male protagonist’s development—is never nitpicking. I expect and welcome changes with an adaptation, but there’s a lot in the show for fans to be upset about when writers choose laziness and harmful tropes over the changes one expects from a new medium.

Stefan Huddleston
Colorado Spings, CO


Readers
“The time has come,” The Walrus said, “to talk of many things.” Send us a letter, an email (letters@thewalrus.ca), or a tweet, or post on our Facebook page. Comments may be published in any medium and edited for length, clarity, and accuracy. Mail correspondence to: 411 Richmond St. E., Suite B15, Toronto, Ontario, Canada  M5A 3S5

Join our community

Jennifer Hollett I have been digging into the pages of The Walrus Summer Reading issue and remarking at all of the contributions from our former and current Fellows. It reminds me that every issue of The Walrus is a result of a culmination of efforts (including lengthy fact-checking) from the editorial team, the emerging journalists they train, and the generous supporters who make all of this happen.

Through The Walrus Editorial Fellowship Program, we have the privilege of training the next generation of professionals who are passionate about the integrity of journalism. In the Summer Reading issue, 2021 Cannonbury Fellow Connor Garel wrote a piece on Frankie Perez and the art of breaking. Tajja Isen contributed an excerpt from her first book, Some of my Best Friends. Isen, who also began her career at The Walrus as a Cannonbury Fellow, is currently Editor-in-Chief at Catapult magazine.

Our 2022 Chawkers Fellow, Mashal Butt, was instrumental in making sure we got the facts straight in our Summer Reading issue, having fact-checked six features, including Sarah Totton’s short story “The Click.” And, you can look forward to a cover story on housing affordability by our 2022 Justice Fund Writer in Residence, JS Rutgers. (Rutgers is now a climate reporter for The Narwhal.)

Donations of any amount (great or small) mean that we can keep on training future journalists in the rigorous practice of fact-checking and editing. With your support, we can continue to keep The Walrus available to readers everywhere as well as help foster the next generation of reporters, copy-editors, fact-checkers, and editors.

With gratitude,

Jennifer Hollett
Executive Director, The Walrus